Anaplan vs Planful: Complete Comparison
Finance leaders in mid-market manufacturing ($100M–$10B) are weighing platform agility against finance velocity. This guide compares Anaplan and Planful across architecture, consolidation, AI updates, implementation, ROI, and fit so you can prioritize speed versus rigor in 2025.
Executive Summary
Anaplan and Planful both evolved in 2025, but their DNA remains distinct. Anaplan is the platform-level choice—extensible modeling spanning finance and operations, built for complex planning ecosystems. Planful is the finance-system choice—an end-to-end FP&A and consolidation suite focused on rapid close cycles, fast forecasting, and AI-assisted workflows for lean finance teams.
Choose Anaplan when you need broad modeling agility and enterprise-wide connected planning. Choose Planful when speed, close automation, and a strong FP&A core without heavy buildout are the priority.
Quick Comparison Snapshot
Architecture & Data Model
Anaplan
Multi-tenant SaaS with proprietary Hyperblock + Polaris engine supporting billions of cells and complex hierarchies. 2025 releases introduced Data Orchestrator 2.0, including Google Cloud Storage integration and improved model-to-model connectivity, reducing reliance on external ETL tooling.
Planful
Finance-centric unified cloud platform. 2025 updates embedded AI Predict and AI Assistant modules across planning, close, and reporting workflows. Dimensional data model emphasizes governance and consolidation readiness rather than open-ended modeling.
Planning & Modeling Philosophy
Anaplan
Champions connected planning—business-owned model building, real-time collaboration, shared data across functions. Ideal when production, sales, workforce, and finance plans must iterate in sync.
Planful
Streamlines FP&A with guided templates for budgeting, forecasting, and workforce planning. AI Assistants generate forecasts, anomaly detection, and narrative commentary, accelerating manual modeling cycles.
Consolidation & Close
Anaplan
Financial Consolidation & Reporting now includes multi-GAAP support, IC matching, and disclosure management. Ideal when consolidation should live inside the same planning ecosystem already using Anaplan.
Planful
Consolidations Premium (2025) delivers mature GAAP/IFRS capabilities—currency translation, NCI handling, intercompany elimination, dynamic journals—all tightly integrated with FP&A. Roadmap extends automated variance explanations and AI-assisted account reconciliation.
Reporting & Analytics
Anaplan
Customizable management reporting and KPI dashboards via the UX app, with Excel Add-ins for power users. 2025 introduced cross-model dashboard linking and enhanced drill-through.
Planful
Integrates financial, management, and operational reporting in one governed environment. AI-generated insights and narrative commentary appear directly inside reports. Seamless export to Excel and BI tools remains standard.
Implementation & Partner Ecosystem
Pricing & Licensing
Both platforms use subscription licensing. Anaplan tiers by workspace size and user type (model builder, contributor, viewer). Planful tiers by modules (FP&A, Consolidation, Reporting) plus user mix.
Typical three-year TCO benchmarks (license only):
• Anaplan: ≈ $400K–$1M depending on number of models/functions.
• Planful: ≈ $250K–$700K for FP&A + Consolidation footprint.
Implementation services usually add 40–60% of license cost. Structure contracts to cover integrations, data orchestration, and change management.
ROI & TCO Outlook
Ideal Use-Cases & Fit
Choose Anaplan if...
- You manage complex operational drivers (production, inventory, sales) and need integrated scenarios.
- You’re scaling across multiple business units/geographies requiring cross-functional alignment.
- You want a platform you can continuously extend beyond finance.
Choose Planful if...
- You need a faster close with lean finance staff.
- You’re focused on FP&A productivity and AI-assisted reporting rather than broad modeling.
- You want consolidation depth plus forecasting inside a governed suite with rapid ROI.
2025 Highlights & Roadmap
Anaplan Highlights
- Continuous monthly releases and major UX upgrades.
- New Data Orchestrator connectors and API enhancements.
- Recognized in Gartner MQ for Financial Consolidation & Close.
Planful Highlights
- AI Assist launch covering forecast, anomaly detection, and narrative.
- Consolidation module enhancements and Perform community expansion.
- Named Challenger in the 2025 Gartner MQ.
Verdict / Analyst Take
Anaplan remains the gold standard for enterprise-wide planning agility—flexible, extensible, built to span departments. Planful has matured into a best-in-class mid-market finance suite—faster to implement, with credible consolidation and emerging AI strengths.
Both vendors innovate rapidly. Anchor your decision on the primary friction: cross-functional alignment (lean Anaplan) versus finance process velocity (lean Planful).
Demand volatility and operational interdependencies require continuous scenario agility.
Close automation, AI-assisted productivity, and lean finance workflows drive the business case.
Many manufacturers deploy Planful for the finance backbone and bring in Anaplan for broader connected planning as complexity grows.
Next Reports
Continue exploring EPM vendor comparisons and guides
FAQs
Which platform handles consolidation better in 2025?
Planful’s Consolidations Premium delivers mature GAAP/IFRS capabilities with currency translation, non-controlling interest handling, intercompany elimination, and dynamic journals baked into the finance workflow. Anaplan’s Financial Consolidation & Reporting has grown substantially and is ideal when you already use Anaplan for planning and want consolidation in the same ecosystem, but it still requires stronger model governance to match Planful’s out-of-the-box depth.
How do Anaplan and Planful differ on pricing?
Both follow subscription pricing. Anaplan tiers by workspace size and user type (model builder, contributor, viewer). Planful tiers by modules (FP&A, Consolidation, Reporting) plus user mix. CFO Shortlist benchmarks show mid-market three-year TCO of roughly $0.4M–$1.0M for Anaplan deployments spanning multiple functions and $0.25M–$0.7M for Planful covering FP&A plus consolidation, with services typically adding 40–60% of license cost.
Sources
- Anaplan product releases, Data Orchestrator documentation, 2025 roadmap briefings.
- Planful Perform 2025 announcements, AI Assist launch materials, consolidation documentation.
- Gartner MQ (2025) for Financial Planning and for Financial Close.
- CFO Shortlist manufacturing EPM benchmark data (2024–2025).
Need an EPM Shortlist?
Our analysts can help you narrow vendors and build ROI guardrails in under 48 hours—reach out when you're ready.
Book a 20-min Consultation