Advisory Services

Evaluation support that meets you where you are.

Whether you're exploring your options or stuck between two finalists — we help mid-market finance teams select the right EPM platform, faster, with full confidence.

13+
years on the vendor side
$0
vendor compensation
8–12
week avg. evaluation
Two Ways In

Start wherever you are.

60 min$199

Direction Session

A structured session to clarify your situation, understand the vendor landscape and define a confident next step — without any vendor noise.

Clear answer: do you actually need a new tool?
Fit-snapshot across vendor categories
Next-step plan based on your timing and budget

Perfect for: CFOs/Controllers who feel early, unsure or overwhelmed

Book Direction Session
90 min$349

Orientation Session

Deep scoping session to map your requirements, assess organizational readiness and build a structured evaluation approach before committing to a process.

Requirements priority stack (Must / Should / Nice)
Readiness assessment and risk flags
Evaluation roadmap with timeline and milestones

Perfect for: Teams ready to start but wanting structure before engaging vendors

Book Orientation Session

Not sure which? Start with a free 25-minute call — no commitment, no vendors.

Modular Evaluation Phases

Engage on the phase you need — or bundle for end-to-end support.

Every service maps to a phase of the evaluation lifecycle. Pick one, pick three, or let us run the whole process.

Phase 01

Needs Analysis

Define requirements before a single demo.

We work with your team to define planning, close and reporting requirements across the organization. Surface process gaps, data constraints and integration dependencies. Establish clear, weighted success criteria that every stakeholder agrees on — so your evaluation starts from a position of clarity, not confusion.

What's included

Stakeholder interviews and requirement extraction
Process gap and data constraint analysis
Weighted evaluation criteria development
Requirements document ready for vendor demos
Quick-buy90 min

Requirements Triage Session

$299

Extract, prioritize and structure the requirements that will actually matter in your evaluation.

Priority requirement stack (Must / Should / Nice)
Initial evaluation criteria
Risk flags based on your workflows and data flows
Phase 02

Vendor Shortlist

Eliminate the noise. Evaluate what's worth it.

We map your requirements to the vendor landscape and eliminate platforms that don't fit your scope, budget or architecture. The result is a focused shortlist of 3–5 vendors — defensible, aligned across stakeholders and ready for structured demos. No more seeing 8 vendors because someone on the team got a cold email.

What's included

Vendor landscape mapping against your requirements
Technical fit and ICP analysis
Scenario-based evaluation matrix
Stakeholder-aligned shortlist with rationale
Quick-buy60 min

Shortlist Validation Call

$199

Expert teardown of your in-progress shortlist to ensure you aren't missing a better-fit vendor or carrying dead weight.

Keep / Replace / Add recommendations
Fit-risks by vendor
Updated shortlist (3–5 vendors max)
Phase 03

Software Evaluation

Structure demos around substance, not theater.

We structure demos around your actual use cases, apply consistent scoring and provide neutral context on each platform's strengths and tradeoffs. Your team sees what matters — not what the vendor wants to show. Every demo runs from the same script, scored on the same criteria, with practitioner-level context on what the platform actually does well and where it struggles.

What's included

Custom demo scripts based on your use cases
Consistent scoring framework across all vendors
Neutral context on each platform's strengths and gaps
POC/Pilot oversight when applicable
Quick-buy90 min

A-vs-B Decision Session

$349

Comparative analysis of your two finalists so you can make a defensible, confident decision.

Side-by-side "real differences that matter"
Implementation complexity reality check
Recommended winner with rationale
Phase 04

Contract Terms

Negotiate from a stronger position.

We assess pricing, scope and commercial terms against benchmarks from 1,000+ evaluations. Identify hidden costs, renewal traps and scope gaps. Help you negotiate terms that protect your organization — not just close the deal. Most mid-market buyers leave 15–30% on the table because they don't know what "normal" looks like.

What's included

Pricing benchmark analysis against comparable deals
Hidden cost and renewal risk identification
Term and structure improvement recommendations
Negotiation strategy and talking points
Quick-buy60 min

Proposal & Pricing Teardown

$299

Surgical review of your vendor's proposal and pricing with benchmarks, risk flags and negotiation angles.

Benchmark-based pricing analysis
Term & structure improvement recommendations
Negotiation script for your next vendor call
Phase 05

Delivery QA

Keep implementation aligned to outcomes.

We review implementation plans and staffing before kickoff. Flag design, integration and data risks early. Provide ongoing buyer-side QA at key milestones to keep delivery aligned to the outcomes you signed up for — not the outcomes that are easiest for the SI to deliver.

What's included

Implementation plan and architecture review
SI/vendor staffing and overlap analysis
Milestone-based quality assurance checkpoints
Risk identification and mitigation guidance
Quick-buy60–90 min

Implementation Plan Review

$299

Expert review of your implementation plan to catch risks before they turn into cost, timeline or rework problems.

Architecture & modeling risk assessment
SI/vendor overlap clarity
Recommended success checkpoints
End-to-End

Need end-to-end support?

Bundle multiple phases into a single engagement. We scope it to your situation — from requirements through selection, commercial terms and implementation QA.

$8,000 – $20,000

Scoped to your evaluation complexity and timeline

Discuss a Full Engagement
Recent Engagements

Real evaluations. Real outcomes.

Mid-MarketFP&A Platform Selection

$50M SaaS / Education Company

FP&A Platform Selection

Challenge: Replacing NetSuite with no viable native planning tool. Needed a standalone FP&A platform that could integrate with their new ERP.

Outcome: Defined requirements, shortlisted vendors, structured demos and reached a final selection decision in 4 weeks.

Selection complete in 4 weeks
EnterpriseFP&A + Consolidation Comparison

$5B Medical Device Manufacturer

FP&A + Consolidation Comparison

Challenge: Complex FP&A and consolidation platform comparison across 3 vendors and 3 regions with competing stakeholder priorities.

Outcome: Provided independent vendor context, scoring frameworks and tradeoff analysis to align the evaluation team across regions.

3 vendors · 3 regions · 1 framework
Why CFO Shortlist

What makes this different.

13+ Years on the Vendor Side

We've seen how vendors pitch, where demos mislead and what contract terms actually matter. That experience helps you cut through the noise and land on the right platform.

No Implementation Revenue

We don't implement anything — which means we never recommend a platform we get paid to deploy. Our only incentive is helping you pick the right one.

8–12 Weeks, Not 9+ Months

Our framework compresses timelines — not by cutting corners, but by eliminating the drift that makes most evaluations stall. Requirements in days. Shortlist in a week. Decision in weeks.

FAQ

Common questions.

Ready to get started?

Most clients start with a Direction Session. 60 minutes, $199, no commitment beyond the session itself.

Independent FP&A & EPM advisory for mid-market finance teams.

Helping CFOs, Controllers, and FP&A leaders choose, negotiate, and implement the right finance stack – without pay-to-play bias.

© 2026 CFO Shortlist. All rights reserved.

Independent, buyer-first EPM advisory.

No vendor compensation or pay-to-play sponsorships.